The death of a child is an unimaginable tragedy, but when a parent is responsible, it becomes even more heart-wrenching. This is the story of Ellie Plumber, an 18-month-old girl whose life was tragically cut short due to the neglect of her own mother, Cheyenne Hill.
The Discovery of Ellie’s Injuries
On November 23, 2022, Cheyenne Hill brought Ellie to Riley Hospital for Children in Indianapolis, Indiana. The young girl presented with a horrific array of injuries: a broken collarbone, bruises on her face, a swollen head, and most concerning, a brain bleed. Doctors determined Ellie’s condition was critical, with a slim chance of survival.
First responders, capturing their interactions on body camera footage, noted the severity of Ellie’s injuries. The bruises on her face were particularly alarming, resembling cigarette burns. This immediately raised red flags, and a homicide investigation was launched.
A History of Abuse Unfolds
Disturbingly, this wasn’t the first time authorities had received reports of potential abuse concerning Ellie. The Department of Children’s Services had a record of a tip just six days prior to Ellie’s hospitalization. The report mentioned “strong chemical drug-like smells” and marijuana coming from the apartment where Ellie lived with her mother and two other children. It also described “lightened bruises” on Ellie’s face, which Hill attributed to a fall from bed.
The tip itself is a chilling reminder of the importance of reporting suspected child abuse. As stated by child welfare advocate, Sarah Jones, “A simple phone call could mean the difference between life and death for a vulnerable child.”
A Mother’s Lies Unravel
As the investigation progressed, detectives interviewed Hill multiple times. Initially, she claimed Ellie’s injuries resulted from a fall from the bed a week and a half prior. However, the timeline and severity of Ellie’s injuries didn’t align with her story.
Body camera footage of Cheyenne Hill
Throughout various interviews, Hill’s story changed, and she began pointing fingers at others, including her boyfriend and neighbors. She even went so far as to compare Ellie to infamous serial killer Jeffrey Dahmer, claiming the toddler was “not a nice kid.” This disturbing statement, coupled with Hill’s erratic behavior and shifting narratives, further incriminated her.
Justice for Ellie
Nearly a year after Ellie’s death, in September 2023, Cheyenne Hill was arrested and charged with neglect of a dependent resulting in death. Court documents revealed Hill had left for work knowing Ellie was in critical condition, prioritizing her own needs over her daughter’s life.
After a trial that exposed the horrific truth of Ellie’s short life, a jury found Hill guilty. In April, she was sentenced to 30 years in prison.
Remembering Ellie
Ellie Plumber’s tragic story is a stark reminder that child abuse can happen anywhere and that it’s everyone’s responsibility to report any suspicions. The pain and suffering Ellie endured at the hands of someone who should have protected her is unimaginable.
While nothing can bring Ellie back, her story serves as a powerful call to action. We must remain vigilant, support organizations fighting child abuse, and advocate for the safety and well-being of all children.