The tragic death of 10-year-old Iliana “Lily” Peters in Chippewa Falls, Wisconsin, sent shockwaves through the community and beyond. In April 2022, Lily was found tragically murdered, and the suspect, identified as CTPB in court documents, was shockingly, a 14-year-old at the time. Now, after numerous appeals and legal battles, the court has ruled that CTPB will face trial as an adult.
Lily’s story is a heartbreaking one. The young girl was last seen riding her bike to her aunt’s house, a seemingly ordinary spring day that turned into every parent’s worst nightmare. When Lily never made it to her destination, a frantic search ensued. Sadly, Lily’s bike was found abandoned in the woods, and the following day, her body was discovered nearby.
The horrific details of the case only amplified the community’s grief and outrage. According to court documents, CTPB admitted to luring Lily off the trail, striking her multiple times, and strangling her before attempting to sexually assault her. To further compound the horror, CTPB returned to the scene to conceal Lily’s body, demonstrating a chilling awareness of his actions.
Given the severity of the crime and the disturbing details revealed in the investigation, the state of Wisconsin sought to charge CTPB as an adult, a move permitted under Wisconsin law for individuals 10 years or older accused of first or second-degree homicide.
CTPB’s defense team fought vigorously to have the case transferred to juvenile court, presenting expert testimony from psychologists who diagnosed CTPB with autism spectrum disorder and other mental health conditions. They argued that CTPB’s developmental delays and psychological vulnerabilities warranted treatment within the juvenile system rather than the harsh realities of adult prison.
Image Description
A scenic image of a park in Chippewa Falls, Wisconsin, a stark contrast to the grim details of the Lily Peters murder case.
“Putting CTPB in adult prison for life is not necessary,” his attorneys argued, emphasizing the need for rehabilitation and treatment rather than punitive measures. However, the prosecution countered that the nature of the crime, the premeditation involved, and the attempted cover-up demonstrated a level of criminal intent that transcended any developmental or psychological challenges.
“These actions were planned and deliberate,” stated former NYPD detective Tom Smith when discussing the case. “The attempt to conceal the body after the fact shows he fully understood the gravity of what he had done.”
Ultimately, the three-judge panel tasked with reviewing the case agreed with the lower court’s decision to try CTPB as an adult. The court found that the trial court had carefully considered the evidence, applied the appropriate legal standards, and reached a reasonable conclusion in keeping the case within the adult criminal justice system.
This decision represents a significant development in the pursuit of justice for Lily Peters. While CTPB’s defense team is appealing the ruling to the Wisconsin Supreme Court, the appeals court’s decision reflects the severity of the crime and the community’s demand for accountability. The tragic loss of Lily Peters serves as a stark reminder of the vulnerability of children and the devastating impact of violence.